Scott Beck and Bryan Woods’s Heretic is a thoughtful, unsettling horror film. The story follows Mr. Reed (Hugh Grant), a staunch atheist who lures two young Mormon missionaries, Sister Barnes (Sophie Thatcher) and Sister Paxton (Chloe East), into a psychological trap. What begins as a simple chat about faith quickly turns into a gripping battle of ideas, as the women are forced to confront their beliefs on Reed’s unsettling terms.
The tension builds slowly but effectively. Reed’s polite invitation and calm demeanor mask his true intentions, as he draws the missionaries into a discussion that becomes increasingly invasive and challenging. This isn’t a film about scares, but about the shifting power dynamics between Reed and the women, as he tests the strength of their convictions and they, in turn, reveal new depths of their faith.
Hugh Grant gives an engaging performance, capturing Reed’s of charm and underlying hostility. Thatcher and East are excellent, portraying the missionaries with authenticity as they navigate their difficult choices. Their characters are complex and grounded, showing faith as something active and evolving rather than rigid.
In its final act, Heretic leaves viewers with interesting reflections on the nature of belief and doubt. A restrained approach to horror and its focus on character makes it a worthy watch.
Heretic releases in Australian cinemas on November 28.
Read more Movie Reviews from Screen Brief.
For more movie news and commentary, follow Screen Brief on social media. Find us on Twitter, YouTube, and Instagram.
