Clayface is a totally gruesome gore-fest that holds nothing back. It goes all the way with its grotesque imagery. The story builds perfect tension, with a mix of gore, horrible tragedy, and eventually hilarious absurdity that turns into fun. The film goes from darkly depressing to wacky, colourful, and absurd. A welcome change of pace that proves DC can do it all.
Clayface stars Tom Rhys Harries as Matt Hagen, a famous actor in Gotham City who becomes horribly disfigured and undergoes experimental surgery to fix his face. When the surgery goes wrong, his skin begins to melt into clay, giving him the power to change into any person’s appearance.
Ripped from the pages of more than 85 years of Batman comic books, Clayface is an iconic villain known for his unique ability to combine his acting skills with his shape-shifting to impersonate anyone. The film takes a more chaotic approach to the character, focusing on the truly brutal and grotesque elements of his disfigurement, and eventually his descent into a mad, unrelenting, violent villain.
Director James Watkins treats Matt Hagen as a complex tragic character but is refreshingly unafraid to make him truly evil by the end. We feel sad for Matt thanks to the script’s well-told backstory, but this is challenged by how unrelentingly violent he turns. It moves swiftly but dedicates enough time to each of its parts to build that resonance. Narratively it’s also super clever how it uses Clayface’s powers, the fact that by the end the audience are guessing who Clayface really is, who might be real, and who might be impersonated by him, is a testament to how well the script understands how to play with his trick. The combination of Flanagan’s script with Watkins’ clever and inventive filmmaking results in massively satisfying tension!

In particular, the level of brutality in the violence is sure to carry some weight with horror fans, with a few scenes standing out as must-see moments simply for how incredibly graphic they are while still being entertaining and giddy.
What’s even more refreshing is that the film is hilariously fun. That is, it’s fun in the sense that it is delightfully satisfying to see the film relish in how ghastly disgusting it can be. Director James Watkins knows exactly how to indulge audiences in awfully brutal body horror that is still entertaining without being repulsive. That comes from a level of self-awareness the film has to acknowledge its own absurdity.
Audiences will gasp at moments where Matt Hagen finds himself in unimaginably dire situations, whether it’s the state of his own body falling apart as he tries to perilously cut his own skin off while it sews his own eyes shut, or the damage he does to others before he even realises how powerful he’s become.
Even better, the film eventually buys into its full premise of absurdity and goes full villain-mode allowing Clayface to actually have fun with his powers in a brilliantly satisfying culmination. The third act features a major set piece that is perfectly put together in its choice of music, its action choreography and the giddy, charming, yet unnerving performance from Tom Rhys Harries.
All that is delivered before a final ending that returns the film to its more reflective, melancholic notes, cementing its script in telling a deeply tragic story.

That said, the script could have done with some improvement to lean more into the introspective aspects of the character’s journey. There is more potential there for Hagen to become lost in an existential crisis, as an actor who lost his perfect face, but can now mould himself into anyone. That sort of identity shift and loss of meaning is deeply interesting, but it’s ultimately something the film only considers in passing.
It is more concerned with the brutal violence, revenge plot, and tragic romance at the heart of it, which are all things it does exceptionally well. In fairness, the tonal shift to being more absurdly comedic, dark and twisted is probably the right choice, and one that wouldn’t square well with a script that tries to also be deeply introspective.
Harries gives an outstanding performance in the leading role. He is so deeply charming, a perfect visual fit, and effortlessly snarky and confident. Ideal for portraying a famous actor while also being great at playing the tragic notes.

The visual language of Gotham City is also superb, being very grungy, with nice neon lighting at night, great world building, including the poorer neighbourhoods like the narrows, a clearly corrupt Gotham police force that good cops try to fight against, and a story that draws out connections between cops, mob bosses and gangs.
What’s so exciting is the versatility of this character means he can now show up anywhere, as anyone, in the DCU. And we certainly look forward to that!
Clayface mixes body horror with tragic elements and hilariously choreographed entertaining moments. Clayface is a satisfyingly brutal descent into grotesque madness that proves DC can do it all.
Clayface is in cinemas October 23.
If you enjoyed our Clayface review, check out more from Screen Brief below.
Read more Movie Reviews from Screen Brief.






